Annuities: The Good, The Bad, and The 'Guaranteed'

Say the word "annuity" in a room full of retirees and watch what happens. Eyes glaze over. Heads shake. Someone will inevitably say, "Aren't those the things with all the fees?" or "My broker said I should never buy one of those."

Here's the thing: they're not entirely wrong. But they're not entirely right, either.

Annuities have a reputation problem: and honestly, some of it is deserved. But when you're staring down retirement and facing the reality of 14 potential 40% market drops over your lifetime, the conversation changes. Suddenly, words like "guaranteed" and "certainty" start sounding a lot better than "hope" and "stay the course."

So let's cut through the noise. No sales pitch. No fear tactics. Just an honest look at annuities pros and cons retirement planning, what "guaranteed" actually means, and whether these tools belong in your plan.

The Bad: Let's Start With the Ugly Truth

I'm not going to sugarcoat it: some annuities are terrible. Complex, expensive, and designed more for the person selling them than the person buying them.

High fees top the list. Some variable annuities come loaded with management fees, mortality and expense charges, rider fees, and underlying fund expenses that can easily hit 3% or more per year. That's a lot of your money walking out the door before you even see a return.

Lack of liquidity is another legitimate concern. Most annuities come with surrender periods: often 5 to 10 years: where pulling your money out early means paying hefty penalties. If you need access to your cash for an emergency or opportunity, you might be stuck.

Complexity is the third strike. Some annuity contracts read like they were written by lawyers for lawyers. Caps, participation rates, spreads, riders: it's a lot. And when you don't understand what you own, you can't make good decisions.

Here's the bottom line: not all annuities are created equal. Some are designed to generate big commissions. Others are built to solve real retirement problems. The trick is knowing the difference.

The Good: What Annuities Actually Do Well

Now for the part Wall Street doesn't want you to hear: when used correctly, annuities can solve problems the market can't.

Guaranteed lifetime income is the big one. An annuity is the only financial tool that can promise you won't outlive your money. You hand over a lump sum, and in return, you get a paycheck for life: whether you live to 75 or 105. The insurance company takes on the longevity risk, not you.

Think about what that means. No more worrying about sequence-of-returns risk. No more wondering if your 4% withdrawal rate is too aggressive. No more watching CNBC with your heart in your throat every time the market dips. You know exactly what's coming in, every single month, for the rest of your life.

Protection from market crashes is the second superpower. Fixed and fixed-index annuities don't participate in market losses. When the market drops 40% (and remember, that happens about every 6 years on average), your annuity balance doesn't move. Zero downside. That's not "staying the course": that's opting out of the roller coaster entirely.

Tax-deferred growth means your money compounds without the IRS taking a cut every year. This isn't unique to annuities, but it's still a benefit worth noting, especially in non-qualified accounts where most investments generate annual tax bills.

Peace of mind might sound soft, but it's real. There's a reason retirees with guaranteed income sources report higher satisfaction levels. When you know your basic expenses are covered no matter what, you sleep better. You stress less. You actually enjoy retirement instead of constantly checking your portfolio.

The "Guaranteed": Why This Word Changes Everything

Here's where we need to get specific, because not all guarantees are created equal.

Fixed annuities guarantee both a specific interest rate and your payout amounts. You know exactly what you're getting, when you're getting it, and how much. It's boring. It's predictable. And when you're facing 14 potential 40% market drops over your retirement, boring and predictable start looking pretty attractive.

Fixed-index annuities guarantee you won't lose money in market downturns while giving you a shot at upside when the market performs well. There are caps and participation rates: you won't capture 100% of market gains: but you also won't suffer 100% of market losses. It's asymmetric risk: limited upside, zero downside.

Variable annuities with guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefits (GMWBs) promise a certain income stream even if your underlying investments tank. The guarantees here are more about income than account value, and they come with higher fees, but they still provide a floor.

The key question isn't "Are annuities good or bad?" The real question is: "What problem am I trying to solve?"

If your problem is outliving your money, an annuity with guaranteed lifetime income solves it.

If your problem is losing 40% of your nest egg right before or after retirement with no time to recover, an annuity with principal protection solves it.

If your problem is lying awake at night wondering if your portfolio will make it through the next crash, an annuity with guarantees solves it.

The Wall Street Alternative: Activity, Hope, and "Staying the Course"

Now contrast that with what Wall Street offers: activity.

Your broker calls when the market drops. "Don't worry, this is normal. Stay the course." They rebalance your portfolio, maybe shift some allocations, generate some trades. It feels like action. It feels like they're doing something.

But here's what they're not doing: guaranteeing anything.

Wall Street loves volatility because volatility generates activity, and activity generates fees. When you're nervous, you call. When you call, they trade. When they trade, they earn. It's a beautiful business model: for them.

The problem is, you're not running a business. You're trying to retire without running out of money or having a heart attack every time the market hiccups.

Wall Street's solution is hope. Hope the market recovers. Hope you don't retire at the wrong time. Hope sequence-of-returns risk doesn't destroy you. Hope you can stomach another 40% drop at age 72.

Hope is not a plan.

So... Should You Buy an Annuity?

Maybe. Maybe not. It depends entirely on your situation, your goals, and what keeps you up at night.

Here's what I know: if you're approaching retirement or already there, guaranteed income you can't outlive matters more than bragging rights at the country club. Market participation sounds exciting until the market crashes and takes your retirement with it.

The Million Dollar Hour™ exists precisely for this reason: to help you see, clearly and objectively, where your current plan actually leads. Not where your broker says it leads. Not where the marketing brochures promise it leads. Where the numbers, the rules, and the reality lead.

We look at guaranteed retirement income options, retirement income planning strategies that prioritize certainty over excitement, and whether tools like annuities make sense for your specific situation. No cookie-cutter answers. No sales pitch. Just clarity.

Because the opposite of confusion isn't complexity. It's certainty. And sometimes, the most radical thing you can do is choose boring, guaranteed, and predictable over exciting, hopeful, and risky.

Ready for clarity instead of confusion?
The Million Dollar Hour™ is your educational, one-on-one retirement review that reveals where your plan leads : not just where it's been.
👉 Schedule your session today.

Keywords

Annuities Pros and Cons, Guaranteed Lifetime Income, Retirement Income Strategies, Safe Wealth Growth, Million Dollar Hour.